Game Developer

GamesIndustry.biz

Hacker News

Valve has raised concerns regarding Mastercard’s influence on gaming platforms in relation to adult content sales. Although Mastercard has publicly denied exerting pressure on platforms like Steam and <a href="http://Itch.io" target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow">Itch.io</a> through direct intervention, Valve insists that intermediaries such as payment processors are referencing Mastercard’s guidelines to enforce content restrictions. According to Valve, payment processors have rejected Steam’s established policy of selling only legally distributable games by specifically citing Mastercard’s Rule 5.12.7. This rule allows transactions to be declined if deemed damaging to the brand’s reputation, regardless of the legality of the content involved.
Mastercard maintains its stance of merely providing payment network technology, distancing itself from the accusations that it directly manages transaction restrictions. Nevertheless, Valve claims that companies facilitating these transactions, including Stripe and PayPal, have used Rule 5.12.7 in their pressure tactics against adult content, leading to removals from platforms.
The impact of these restrictions has alarmed several industry groups, who view them as a form of creative suppression surpassing legal restraints. Such constraints particularly affect LGBTQ+ creators, with fears that censorship might hinder the diversity and representation within the gaming community. Valve’s refutation underscores the broader implications of these payment policies on gaming platforms, urging a reevaluation of the balance between brand protection and creative freedom.

Collections

Valve disputes Mastercard's claims about not directly restricting adult content on gaming platforms, arguing that payment processors like Stripe and PayPal use Mastercard's Rule 5.12.7 to pressure platforms into removing adult content. This rule allows transaction declines based on brand reputation concerns, regardless of content legality. Industry groups worry these restrictions suppress creative freedom and particularly impact LGBTQ+ creators, raising concerns about censorship beyond legal requirements in the gaming community.

Valve Challenges Mastercard's Role in Restricting Adult Content on Gaming Platforms